Causes of the Civil War

Philip Leigh

The presently dominant narrative about Civil War causes is the work of historians obsessed with social activism instead of historical facts.

They point to the 13th, 14th and 15th postbellum amendments as proof that the North was fighting to provide slaves with an honorable freedom but deny that the increase in tariffs from 19% before the war to an average of 45% for fifty years thereafter reflected a Northern war aim.

They hold Southern secession responsible for the war but fail to teach that the Northeastern states threatened to secede five times between 1789 and 1850. They also decline to note that Southern secession need not have led to war. Southerners had no purpose to overthrow the Washington government, they merely wanted a government of their own. Northerners could have evacuated Fort Sumter and let the first seven cotton states depart in peace thereby avoiding the war.

Modern historians normally focus on the reasons the cotton states seceded instead of examining the economic reasons Northerners chose to militarily coerce them back into the Union thereby inaugurating civil war.

The Republican Party could have stopped the spread of slavery peacefully by endorsing Popular Sovereignty during the 1860 presidential election. After Kansas used it to reject slavery in an 1858 local-option vote, nearly every politico realized that the doctrine would quarantine slavery in the South. If Popular Sovereignty could not make a slave state out of Kansas, it could not do it in any of the remaining 1860 Federal territories. Republicans rejected the doctrine simply to survive as an independent Party because Lincoln’s two chief opposing presidential candidates supported it. Beyond what Poplar Sovereignty would have gained, the Republican ban added nothing except to inflame the sectional passions that led to civil war.

Paperback ISBN: 978-1947660410

Free Books!

Sign up for Shotwell’s new release notifications and receive the downloadable editions of Lies My Teacher Told Me by Clyde Wilson and When the Yankees Come by Paul C. Graham—absolutely free!

Your information will never be shared and you can unsubscribe anytime.